Soft 404 Errors Explained: Causes, Fixes, and Best Practices

Home >> Blog >> Soft 404 Errors Explained: Causes, Fixes, and Best Practices

TABLE OF CONTENTS

• What Is a Soft 404 Error?
• 404 vs. Soft 404 Errors
• Can Soft 404 Errors Harm SEO?
• How to Find Soft 404 Errors on Your Website
• Common Reasons for Soft 404 Errors
• How to Fix Soft 404 Errors
• What Problems Can Soft 404s Cause?t
• Proactive Measures to Prevent Soft 404 Errors
• Conclusion

In the world of SEO and website management, encountering errors is inevitable. While most website owners are familiar with the standard 404 Not Found error, fewer are aware of its lesser-known cousin: the soft 404 error. Unlike a hard 404, which clearly indicates a missing page, a soft 404 is more subtle—and often more problematic.

A soft 404 error occurs when a webpage returns a 200 OK status code (which means the page is functioning) but lacks meaningful content, leading search engines to treat it as a missing page. This can confuse both users and search engines, harming your website’s SEO and user experience.

Why should you care? Because soft 404 errors can silently damage your website’s performance. They waste crawl budget, reduce indexing efficiency, and frustrate users who land on pages with little to no value. In this blog, we’ll explore what soft 404 errors are, how to identify them, and most importantly, how to fix them to ensure your website remains healthy and optimized for search engines.

What Is a Soft 404 Error?

A soft 404 error is a tricky issue that often goes unnoticed because it doesn’t display the traditional “404 Not Found” message. Instead, it occurs when a webpage appears to be functioning (returning a 200 OK status code) but lacks meaningful content, causing search engines to interpret it as a missing or irrelevant page.

How Search Engines Identify Soft 404 Errors

Search engines like Google use sophisticated algorithms to determine whether a page is valuable or not. When a page has little to no content, or its content doesn’t match the user’s search intent, search engines may classify it as a soft 404. For example:

• A product page that no longer exists but redirects to a generic “out of stock” message.
• A blog category page with no posts or minimal content.
• A page with a “page not found” message but still returns a 200 status code.

Real-World Example of a Soft 404 Error

Imagine you run an e-commerce website, and a customer clicks on a link to a product that’s no longer available. Instead of showing a clear 404 error, the page displays a message like, “This product is currently unavailable,” but still returns a 200 status code. To the user, it’s clear the page isn’t useful, but to search engines, it’s confusing—they see a functioning page with no value.

This mismatch between user experience and server response is what makes soft 404 errors so problematic. They not only waste crawl budget but also harm your website’s credibility and SEO performance.

By understanding the basics of soft 404 errors, you can take the first step toward identifying and resolving them effectively. In the next sections, we’ll dive deeper into how these errors impact your website and what you can do to fix them.

404 vs. Soft 404 Errors

While both 404 and soft 404 errors indicate issues with webpage availability, they differ significantly in how they occur and how they impact your website. Understanding these differences is crucial for effective troubleshooting and SEO optimization.

Hard 404 Errors

• What They Are: A hard 404 error occurs when a webpage is explicitly missing, and the server returns a 404 Not Found status code.
• User Experience: Users see a clear message like “404 Page Not Found,” indicating the page doesn’t exist.
• SEO Impact: While hard 404 errors can harm user experience, they are straightforward for search engines to understand and handle.

Soft 404 Errors

• What They Are: A soft 404 error occurs when a webpage returns a 200 OK status code but lacks meaningful content, leading search engines to treat it as a missing page.
• User Experience: Users may see a page with minimal or irrelevant content, such as a generic “out of stock” message or an empty category page.
• SEO Impact: Soft 404 errors are more harmful because they confuse search engines, waste crawl budget, and can lead to indexing issues.

By understanding these differences, you can better identify and address the specific issues affecting your website.

Can Soft 404 Errors Harm SEO?

Soft 404 errors might seem harmless at first glance, but they can have serious consequences for your website’s SEO performance. Here’s how these errors can hurt your rankings and what you can do to mitigate the damage:

1. Wasted Crawl Budget
   Search engines allocate a limited amount of time and resources (crawl budget) to index your website. When they encounter soft 404 errors, they waste valuable crawl budget on pages that provide no value. This can result in important pages being overlooked or not indexed at all.
2. Reduced Indexing Efficiency
   Soft 404 errors confuse search engines because they return a 200 OK status code but lack meaningful content. This can lead to:
   • Pages being incorrectly indexed as valid content.
   • Important pages being excluded from search results.

   For example, if a product page is no longer available but returns a soft 404, search engines might continue to index it, leading to poor user experiences and lower rankings.

3. Negative Impact on User Experience
   When users land on pages with little to no value, they’re likely to leave your site immediately. This increases your bounce rate, a key metric that search engines use to evaluate user experience. A high bounce rate can signal to search engines that your site isn’t providing value, further hurting your rankings.
4. Potential Penalties Over Time
   If left unchecked, soft 404 errors can accumulate and lead to more severe consequences. Search engines may penalize your site for providing a poor user experience, resulting in lower rankings and reduced organic traffic.
Real-Life Example

A popular blog once experienced a significant drop in traffic after a site migration. Due to improper redirects and thin content, hundreds of pages returned soft 404 errors. As a result, their organic traffic plummeted by 25%, and it took months to recover.

By addressing soft 404 errors promptly, you can protect your website’s SEO performance, improve user experience, and avoid potential penalties.

How to Find Soft 404 Errors on Your Website

Identifying soft 404 errors is the first step toward resolving them. Unlike hard 404 errors, which are easier to detect, soft 404s require a more strategic approach. Here are some effective methods to uncover these hidden issues:

1. Use Google Search Console
   Google Search Console is one of the most reliable tools for identifying soft 404 errors. Here’s how to use it:
   • Navigate to the Coverage Report under the "Index" section.
   • Look for errors labeled “Submitted URL seems to be a soft 404.”
   • Review the list of URLs and analyze the reasons behind the soft 404 classification.

   This tool provides valuable insights into how Google perceives your pages and helps you prioritize fixes.

2. Run a Website Crawl
   Tools like Screaming Frog, Ahrefs, or SEMrush can crawl your website and flag pages that may be returning soft 404 errors. These tools simulate how search engine bots navigate your site and provide detailed reports on:
   • Pages with thin or duplicate content.
   • Pages with low word count or irrelevant content.
   • Pages that redirect to irrelevant or generic messages.

   For example, Screaming Frog can identify pages with a 200 status code but minimal content, which are likely candidates for soft 404 errors.

3. Analyze Server Logs
   Server logs contain detailed information about every request made to your website. By analyzing these logs, you can identify:
   • Pages that return a 200 status code but have high bounce rates.
   • Pages that are frequently accessed but lack meaningful content.

   This method is particularly useful for detecting soft 404 errors that may not appear in other tools.

4. Monitor User Behavior
   Tools like Google Analytics can help you identify pages that may be causing soft 404 errors. Look for:
   • Pages with high bounce rates and low time on page.
   • Pages with low engagement metrics, such as few clicks or conversions.

   By combining these methods, you can create a comprehensive strategy for identifying soft 404 errors and ensuring your website remains healthy and optimized.

Common Reasons for Soft 404 Errors

Soft 404 errors can occur for a variety of reasons, often due to technical issues or poor content management. Understanding these common causes can help you prevent and resolve them effectively.

1. Thin or Low-Quality Content
   Pages with little to no content are prime candidates for soft 404 errors. Examples include:
   • Empty category or tag pages.
   • Placeholder pages with minimal text.
   • Pages with duplicate or auto-generated content.

   For instance, an e-commerce site with empty product category pages may trigger soft 404 errors because search engines see no value in indexing them.

2. Incorrect Redirects
   Improper redirects can lead to soft 404 errors, especially if they point to irrelevant or generic pages. Examples include:
   • Redirecting a deleted product page to a generic “out of stock” message.
   • Redirecting a blog post to a homepage or unrelated content.

   These redirects confuse search engines and users, resulting in soft 404 errors.

3. Server Misconfigurations
   Server issues can also cause soft 404 errors. Common problems include:
   • Pages returning a 200 status code instead of a 404 for missing content.
   • Incorrectly configured .htaccess files or CMS settings.

   For example, if your server is configured to return a 200 status code for missing pages, search engines will interpret them as soft 404s.

4. Outdated or Irrelevant Content
   Pages that are no longer relevant or useful can also trigger soft 404 errors. Examples include:
   • Seasonal or promotional pages that are no longer active.
   • Seasonal or promotional pages that are no longer active.

   By addressing these common causes, you can minimize the risk of soft 404 errors and ensure your website remains optimized for search engines and users alike.

How to Fix Soft 404 Errors

Once you’ve identified soft 404 errors on your website, the next step is to fix them. Here’s a detailed, actionable guide to help you resolve these issues effectively:

1. Add Meaningful Content to Thin Pages
   If a page is flagged as a soft 404 due to thin or low-quality content, consider:
   • Expanding the content to make it more valuable and relevant.
   • Adding images, videos, or other multimedia elements to enhance engagement.
   • Ensuring the content matches the user’s search intent.

   For example, if an empty product category page is causing a soft 404 error, populate it with relevant products or remove the page entirely.

2. Set Up Proper Redirects
   For pages that no longer exist or have been moved, use 301 redirects to guide users and search engines to the correct URL. Avoid redirecting to generic pages like the homepage unless absolutely necessary.
   How to Set Up a 301 Redirect:
   • Use plugins like Redirection (for WordPress) or modify your .htaccess file for non-WordPress sites.
   • Example: Redirect an old blog post to a new, relevant post.
3. Correct Server Configurations
   Ensure your server is configured to return the correct HTTP status codes. For example:
   • Missing pages should return a 404 Not Found status code, not a 200 OK.
   • Use tools like Screaming Frog or Google Search Console to verify status codes.

   If you’re unsure how to configure your server, consult your hosting provider or a developer.

4. Remove or Consolidate Irrelevant Pages
   If a page is no longer relevant or useful, consider:
   • Deleting the page and returning a proper 404 status code.
   • Consolidating similar pages into a single, high-quality page.

   For example, if you have multiple outdated blog posts on the same topic, combine them into one comprehensive guide.

5. Monitor and Test Your Fixes
   After implementing the fixes, use tools like Google Search Console or Screaming Frog to verify that the soft 404 errors have been resolved. Regularly monitor your site for new errors to ensure they don’t pile up.

Real-Life Example

A popular e-commerce site once experienced a surge in soft 404 errors after a site migration. By using Google Search Console and Screaming Frog, they identified over 200 thin or irrelevant pages. They added meaningful content to some pages, set up proper redirects for others, and deleted the rest. As a result, their organic traffic increased by 15% within two months.

By following these steps, you can effectively fix soft 404 errors, improve your website’s SEO, and enhance the user experience.

What Problems Can Soft 404s Cause?

Soft 404 errors might seem like a minor issue, but if left unaddressed, they can have serious long-term consequences for your website. Here’s how these errors can harm your site over time:

1. Reduced Crawl Efficiency
   Search engines allocate a limited amount of time and resources (crawl budget) to index your website. When they encounter soft 404 errors, they waste valuable crawl budget on pages that provide no value. This can result in important pages being overlooked or not indexed at all.
2. Lower Search Engine Rankings
   Soft 404 errors confuse search engines because they return a 200 OK status code but lack meaningful content. Over time, this can lead to:
   • Pages being incorrectly indexed as valid content.
   • Important pages being excluded from search results.

   For example, if a product page is no longer available but returns a soft 404, search engines might continue to index it, leading to poor user experiences and lower rankings.

3. Poor User Experience
   When users land on pages with little to no value, they’re likely to leave your site immediately. This increases your bounce rate, a key metric that search engines use to evaluate user experience. A high bounce rate can signal to search engines that your site isn’t providing value, further hurting your rankings.
4. Damage to Brand Reputation
   Frequent soft 404 errors can make your website appear unprofessional or outdated. For example:
   • If a potential customer clicks on a link from your social media profile and lands on a soft 404 page, they may question the credibility of your business.
   • Users who encounter multiple errors may lose trust in your brand and choose to take their business elsewhere.
5. Lost Revenue Opportunities
   If your website generates revenue through ads, affiliate links, or e-commerce sales, soft 404 errors can directly impact your bottom line. For instance:
   • A broken link to a product page could result in lost sales and dissatisfied customers.
   • Affiliate links that lead to soft 404 pages can cost you valuable commissions.

A well-known blog once experienced a significant drop in traffic after a site migration. Due to improper redirects and thin content, hundreds of pages returned soft 404 errors. As a result, their organic traffic plummeted by 20%, and it took months to recover.

By understanding the long-term impacts of soft 404 errors, you can take proactive steps to prevent them and protect your website’s SEO, user experience, and revenue.

Proactive Measures to Prevent Soft 404 Errors

Preventing soft 404 errors is far easier than fixing them after they occur. By implementing these proactive measures, you can minimize the risk of these errors and ensure your website remains healthy and optimized for search engines.

1. Regularly Audit Your Website
   Conduct regular website audits using tools like Screaming Frog, Ahrefs, or SEMrush to identify and fix potential soft 404 errors. Look for:
   • Pages with thin or low-quality content.
   • Pages with high bounce rates or low engagement metrics.
   • Pages that return a 200 status code but lack meaningful content.
2. Monitor Google Search Console
   Set up alerts in Google Search Console to notify you of soft 404 errors as soon as they occur. Regularly review the Coverage Report to identify and address issues before they escalate.
3. Optimize Content for User Intent
   Ensure every page on your website provides value and matches the user’s search intent. Avoid creating placeholder pages or pages with minimal content. Instead, focus on creating high-quality, engaging content that meets the needs of your audience.
4. Use Proper Redirects
   When moving or deleting pages, always set up 301 redirects to guide users and search engines to the correct URL. Avoid redirecting to generic pages like the homepage unless absolutely necessary.
5. Correct Server Configurations
   Ensure your server is configured to return the correct HTTP status codes. For example:
   • Missing pages should return a 404 Not Found status code, not a 200 OK.
   • Use tools like Screaming Frog or Google Search Console to verify status codes.
6. Educate Your Team
   Ensure everyone involved in managing your website understands the importance of avoiding soft 404 errors. Provide training on best practices for content creation, redirects, and server configurations.

A popular blog implemented a proactive link management strategy, including regular audits and automated tools. As a result, they reduced their soft 404 errors by 90% and saw a 15% increase in organic traffic within six months.

By taking these proactive measures, you can prevent soft 404 errors, improve your website’s SEO, and create a better experience for your users.

Conclusion

Soft 404 errors are a common challenge for website owners, but they don’t have to be a setback. By understanding their causes, identifying them promptly, and implementing effective solutions, you can turn these errors into opportunities to enhance your website’s performance and user experience.

From improving your SEO rankings to building trust with your audience, addressing soft 404 errors is a critical step in maintaining a healthy, high-performing website. Whether it’s setting up proper redirects, creating meaningful content, or conducting regular site audits, every action you take contributes to a smoother, more reliable online presence.

Remember, a well-handled soft 404 error can even leave a positive impression on your visitors. By guiding them back to relevant content with a personalized 404 page, you can turn frustration into engagement and keep them coming back for more.

Don’t let soft 404 errors hold your website back. Take control of your site’s health today by identifying and fixing these errors before they impact your rankings, reputation, and revenue. At CS Web Support, we specialize in helping businesses like yours create seamless digital experiences. Whether you need help with website audits, custom 404 pages, or SEO strategies, our team is here to support you every step of the way.